Monday, April 22, 2013

Unit 1 - P5


P5: Read Hortwiz. How does Horwitz develop his argument for “eating on the edge”? Relate his essay to one example from your own life to illustrate, complicate, or otherwise expand upon Horwitz’s argument.
Horwitz in "Eating at the Edge" begins his argument by defining what it means to "eat on the edge," starting with the fact that students and teachers used to smoke in classrooms. He brings this up because "eating on the edge" is when food is an additive and how it explains how we feel when we eat, whether it be by ourselves or with family and friends. He brings in a great analogy with watching TV, and how with the introduction of the DVR, watching a TV show on its aired schedule is no longer the only conventional way to watch TV. He equates this to this phenomenon called "grazing" where meals are not eaten at fixed times which was quoted to be a "timeless time." This in turn brings up the question of eating on the edge, and how it is being used to divert from social interactions like with the astronauts who preferred to eat snacks as they worked rather than sit in the triangular tray table. As the schedule to eat food becomes more erratic, sharing food with others becomes less common. In fact, it seems that the food industry is the one that is catering to this new trend such as restaurants who hang "cuisine tout la journée" on their quarters to show that they will serve the same menu regardless of the time of day. An example in my own life is how I deal with college as a pre-med student. My schedule is overwhelmed with all the sciences and labs which take a lot of time out of my day. Since I always feel so pressed for time, I find myself not eating at regular times to be able to finish my work; only afterwards, when I've found reprieve and finished pressing matters do I then decide to get something to eat. And even when I do get something to eat, it's mostly from the small store at Olin where I can just pick something and go. I rarely opt to go to the cafeteria for the very reason that going there is quite a hassle than the conventionality of premade foods that are accessible with a swipe of the card.

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

SE3


Keane Lim
WRIT 1133
Professor Eric Leake
11 April 2013
Vietnamese Food Culture
            A cultural phenomena that I was interested in investigating was how cultures create their own community through food in a different country. One example of this in America is how expats from Vietnam have proliferated in the food industry with their Pho restaurants. In casual conversation, dishes like pho have become representative of Vietnamese cuisine. How has Vietnamese food culture created its own niche despite being displaced from their home country and in turn, has it been affected by this external influence?
            As I was seated to my table at a pho restaurant that I go to often, I was caught off-guard by a question I had never been asked before: "Would you like chopsticks or utensils to eat your pho today?" This became the focus of my observations as I realized that not all customers shared the same customs as me as an Asian-American who normally ate with chopsticks. I noticed that while some Americans used the chopsticks, many opted to use forks and spoons.  In Asia, chopsticks are customary for eating most dishes but here in America, this cultural tradition seemed not to hold as much importance as it would in the home country.
            This opened my eyes to the fact that there are some behaviors that we do, that we are not consciously aware about. These mannerisms exhibit food values and culture such as with etiquette in how we eat. Another example of food value and culture in the Vietnamese community is that it is proper etiquette to slurp your soup to let the chefs know that you enjoyed the meal.Other customers did this, too, as they were talking to the people at their table, but I wondered if that crucial aspect of the Vietnamese food culture was even known to the other customers who ate pho here or if it was by coincidence.  
            With some introspection, I thought whether or not I was oblivious to food values and culture in a different community like in European influenced restaurants. For example, even though pho has become an iconic order for many people at these restaurants, I noticed that very few people ordered the other dishes on the menu.  For the one hour I was there, I saw only one order that was not pho: spring rolls. Granted, since pho is in the restaurant name, one might argue that this observation of mostly pho orders is obvious. However, food culture is home to many other dishes which seem to not be equally and thoroughly enjoyed. Perhaps part of how we perceive food culture depends on how selective we are with the dishes that we eat.
            Another observation that I made with the food value of pho in the Vietnamese community is the name of the restaurant. Most people assume that the numbers of the pho restaurants like Pho 56 means that they were the 56th restaurant in the chain to be made. However, the names of some of these locations actually have significance to the owners. I ended up asking the owner of my particular pho restaurant afterwards, and he told me that he named his restaurant based off the year he left his country of Vietnam to move to America. The owner would go ask some customers as they were paying if they were Vietnamese, and they would communicate in their own dialect. It is really fascinating what a community that have created through food, especially considering Vietnamese's past with its war and Communist regime.
            Alexandra Greeley touches upon the idea of nostalgia for the Vietnamese through Pho in her article "Pho: The Vietnamese Addiction" in Gastronomica. She talks about how a traveler ordered a bowl of pho which "failed to bring to [his] mouth the table of 'Hanoi pho'" despite it having all the same ingredients (Greeley 80). This idea of authenticity of the "pho as [they] knew it" and how there was a migration of the pho recipe from North Vietnam to South Vietnam after the new Communist regime in 1954 is relevant to their food culture (Greeley 81). Since there are so many ways to experiment with making pho, the Vietnamese used to argue about the methods and ingredients. Pho had a different recipe that defined the region of Vietnam that the cook was from. The food values and culture differ depending on whether or not you understand the "purist" sentiments that Vietnamese feel towards pho or if you are just a casual customer (Greeley 82).
            In "Pho Scene in the United States" by Cuong Huynh, he also talks about how this staple dish has transformed culturally, contrasting how it is "not exactly the same as was first loved in Vietnam" by the refugees who came to America. (Huynh 1) These dishes, he wrote, acquired changes to "adapt to the more varied and flexible environment of America" (Huynh 1) which I saw firsthand with the offering of utensils to eat pho. This observation makes me think that food values and culture have also changed to integrate themselves in a newer community.
            While the traditional Vietnamese culture has values toward food that distinguish itself, it has also taken in some food values from other cultures to create a more diverse ingroup. Food appears to be both divisive when a culture is contained in another but also malleable and dynamic to fit the needs of a new environment. Food ethnographies are fascinating because there is so much unsaid and overlooked in the environments that people eat at that speak a lot about food values and culture.

Bibliography
Huynh, Cuong. "Pho Scene in the United States." Ezinarticles, 15 Apr. 2009. Web. 10 Apr. 2013. <http://ezinearticles.com/?Pho-Scene-in-the-United-States---Part-1&id=2223803>.

Alexandra Greeley. "Phở: The Vietnamese Addiction." Gastronomica: The Journal of Food and Culture , Vol. 2, No. 1 (Winter 2002), pp. 80-83. 10 April 2013. < http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdfplus/10.1525/gfc.2002.2.1.80.pdf?acceptTC=true>